Best Pizza Stones

Top 5 Best Pizza Stones in 2021 (Reviewed)

Pizza - the one food that can cure all your sadness. It’s been recreated in so many paces and in so many varieties, that it’s hard to say which place has the best pizza in town.

One thing is sure though - pizzas made in pizzerias are undoubtedly the best. Wonder what’s the secret? It’s not just the open flame.

Pizzerias use a secret thing and it’s not even any food ingredient. It’s the pizza stones. These are the secret behind crispy pizzas. In 21st century, you can bake a pizzeria style pizza at home.

Pizza stones are pretty affordable now and should be used rather than a simple pizza pan! We have found top 5 best pizza stones you can use to bake an ultra-crispy pizza!

Without much ado, let’s find out!

Top 5 Best Pizza Stones in 2021

Image

Product

Features

Check Price

Cast Elegance Pizza Stone

Cast Elegance Pizza Stone

Made from thermite, a type of cordierite stone

Retains heat for a long time

Unicook Heavy Duty Pizza Grilling Stone

Unicook Heavy Duty Pizza Grilling Stone

Made from cordierite stone

Handles heat up to 1450 C

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan

Made from cast iron

High heat handling capacity

Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone

Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone

Glazed surface

Withstands very high heat

Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper

Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper

Perforated design

Dishwasher safe

Inexpensive

1. Cast Elegance Pizza Stone - Best Overall

Cast Elegance Pizza Stone

Cast Elegance Pizza Stone is one of the best pizza stones in the market. Having received rave reviews, this pizza stone has become a favorite among many. It is made of a synthetic material called cordierite, a rock which is manufactured artificially. Cordierite is used in ceramics. It’s used to make anything resistant to thermal shock. 

Another great thing about this pizza stone is that it can retain the heat for a long time. Pizza going cold after baking is a nightmare. Traditional pizza baking pans are not able to keep the heat. Cast Elegance on the other hand keeps your pizza warm for long time. The pizza also bakes at all sides.

This pizza stone also has a perfect measurement. It’s 16 inches in diameter, so you can cook a family pizza easily. It also easily fits with any oven or cooker you’re using. In fact, you can use gas grill too with this stone. And if you’re worried about melted cheese sticking with the stone, there is actually a free scraper to make your life easier. The cordierite is pretty resilient, and scraping won’t ruin the finishing at all.

PROS:

  • Resilient
  • Sustains thermal shock
  • Available in multiple sizes
  • Free scraper available

CONS:

  • Synthetic material could be unstable

2. Unicook Heavy Duty Pizza Grilling Stone

Unicook Heavy Duty Pizza Grilling Stone

The name suggests it all! Unicook’s pizza stone is truly heavy duty. It can handle temperature up to 1450C! If you are a fan of ultra crispy bottom of pizza, this one is it. What we love about this pizza stone is that it is authentically the Sicilian pizza stone. Ever wondered why deli pizzas taste so good? It’s not just the brick oven. The stones used to bake pizza are also a huge factor.

Heavy duty pizza stones bring out the real pizza taste. The stone material is the same as the Caste Elegance-cordierite. It’s pretty versatile- you can use it in any type of cooker. Whether it’s an oven, smokers or gas grills-this pizza stone is suitable for all. 

The rectangular shaped pizza stone is 12 inches by 15 inches. That’s large enough to bake a family pizza! The rectangular shape is very handy. You can bake cookies, pastries, loaves-anything you like with this stone. It also comes with a dough cutter-you can use it to cut doughs or even scrape the residue off the stone as well. The only problem of this pizza stone is that it darkens with time.

PROS:

  • Quite large for baking family pizzas
  • Durable
  • Comes with a dough cutter
  • Easily washable
  • Affordable

CONS:

  • Stains very easily

3. Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan

This pizza stone is made from cast iron. If you didn’t know already, cast iron pizzas are just other worldly. It can recreate the classic taste and texture a pizzeria has- crispy, golden brown crust with cheese oozing all over!

Cast iron skillet heats up very quickly and retains that sizzling heat for a long time. It gives your pizza a charry and crispy bottom. This one also comes pre-seasoned, so you can use it instantly. The high heat handling capacity makes it suitable for using on stove top, or even a campfire.

Cast iron pizza stones can be used in many ways. You don’t have to be limited to pizzas only. You can cook bacons, steaks, tortillas-the options are endless.

You may also use it for roasting veggies and meats, bake a bread-anything is possible if you have a cast iron skillet or pizza stone. The ease of use is also praiseworthy- the loop handle makes it easily removable, with or without the mitts. The skillet is 14 inches in diameter and made in USA. 

PROS:

  • Can sustain high heat
  • Maintains heat for a long time
  • Versatile use
  • Easy to use

CONS:

  • A bit heavy
  • Needs additional care

4. Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone

Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone

This pizza stone is made from flame top ceramics. It is made from Burgundian clay. Flame top means you can use it on open flame and it will still be fine! If you love to make pizza on gas grill, this one is the best pizza stone for you.  You can use it in an oven too. The stone can withstand heat up to 900C. There are side handles to make it easy to lift.

The surface of the stone is micro-crazed. If you like even browning of pizzas at the bottom, then micro-crazed surface is a great option to go for. You can just serve up the pizza on the stone itself, ceramics don’t leach into the pizza dough.

Also, it’s very easy to clean up, so don’t worry about melted cheese stuck at the bottom. The stone is washable by hand. The surface is slick, so it doesn’t remain greasy or sticky. You can wash it with soap or detergent, but make sure not to get overexcited and use too much of it.

PROS:

  • Withstands high heat, up to 900C
  • Handles for smooth use
  • Glazed surface
  • Dishwasher safe

CONS:

  • A bit heavy and delicate to handle

5. Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper

Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Crisper

The last one in our Top 5 list is a pizza stone in disguise of a pan. It looks exactly like a traditional pizza pan, but works like a pizza stone. If you’re someone looking for best of both worlds, this is a perfect choice for you.

The name doesn’t lie; you would really get the perfect results with this one. You can get the real pizzeria style pizza from using this one.

The pizza pan is perforated; this allows air to pass through it and gives you a nice and crispy crust on the outside. The side handles help with the ease of use. This 14-inch pizza pan has a 10-year warranty, so make as many pizzas as you want.

This one is also dishwasher safe; you can wash it in warm and soapy water every time after use. It’s durable and doesn’t get affected with the detergent or soap, unlike traditional pizza pans. It’s non-stick, so the pizza comes out without sticking to the bottom. 

PROS:

  • Lightweight
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Perforated design to let air flow through
  • Inexpensive

CONS:

  • Not very versatile
  • Comes in only one size

Final Words

So, these were our top 5 best pizza stones of 2021! 

Each of the pizza stones were chosen based on how much heat they can withstand, washability, how well it can retain heat, price and most of all-how crispy the pizza gets after baking with the pizza stone. Though all of these pizza stones are currently the best performing ones, we do have a favorite.

Our top pick is the Unicook Heavy Duty Pizza Grilling Stone. We think this pizza stone gives the best result- you get an ultra-crispy pizza bottom with oozing cheese! 

It’s very versatile, you can make any type of bread, naan, tortillas on it and even roast veggies! We hope this article helped you pick your own favorite pizza stone for home!